BRADY Quarterback Rankings
Every starter since 1999, on the same scale as RICE. How it works
QuarterbackTeamSeasonsPeak
Peyton Manning
1999–2015104.0Tom Brady
2001–2022101.3Drew Brees
2002–2020101.2Patrick Mahomes
2018–202697.6Philip Rivers
2006–202097.1Aaron Rodgers
2008–202697.0Matt Ryan2008–202296.0Josh Allen
2018–202694.5Lamar Jackson
2018–202694.4Brock Purdy
2022–202693.2Tony Romo
2006–201493.1Kurt Warner
1999–200992.4Ben Roethlisberger2004–202191.5Daunte Culpepper
2000–200491.4Brett Favre1999–201091.1Jared Goff
2017–202690.8Trent Green2001–200690.6Steve McNair1999–200689.9Matt Schaub
2007–201389.9Dak Prescott2016–202689.3Jayden Daniels
2024–202689.2Russell Wilson2012–202489.1Carson Palmer2004–201688.9Ryan Tannehill
2012–202388.4Andy Dalton2011–202288.3David Garrard
2006–201088.2Jalen Hurts
2021–202687.8Matt Hasselbeck2001–201587.7Justin Herbert
2020–202687.1Jeff Garcia1999–200886.9Rich Gannon
1999–200286.2Donovan McNabb2000–201085.8Jake Plummer1999–200685.6Marc Bulger
2003–200985.6Matthew Stafford2009–202685.4Joe Flacco
2008–202585.3Eli Manning
2005–201885.2Jay Cutler
2007–201785.0Joe Burrow2020–202684.9Drake Maye
2024–202684.8Jay Fiedler2000–200384.7Caleb Williams
2024–202684.7Baker Mayfield2018–202684.6Mike Vick2002–201284.5Nick Foles2013–201584.5Mitchell Trubisky2017–202084.4Brad Johnson1999–200684.4Colin Kaepernick2012–201684.3Jordan Love
2023–202684.2Carson Wentz2016–202184.1Kerry Collins2000–200884.1Robert Griffin III2012–201383.9Chad Pennington2002–200883.8Tua Tagovailoa2020–202583.5Kirk Cousins2015–202683.5Brian Griese1999–200483.5Kyler Murray2019–202483.3Daniel Jones2019–202683.1Josh Freeman2009–201282.8Deshaun Watson
2018–202682.2Jake Delhomme
2003–200982.2Mac Jones2021–202582.1Kordell Stewart1999–200182.1Andrew Luck2012–201882.1Derek Carr2014–202481.8Tommy Maddox2002–200381.7Alex Smith2006–201881.7Case Keenum2013–201981.6Jon Kitna1999–201081.6Trevor Lawrence2021–202681.5C.J. Stroud2023–202681.3Mark Brunell1999–200681.2Jimmy Garoppolo2019–202281.2Bryce Young2023–202680.9Matt Cassel2008–201280.5Steve Beuerlein1999–200080.2Jeff George1999–199980.1Vinny Testaverde2000–200479.9Cam Newton2011–202079.8Derek Anderson2007–201079.8Jaxson Dart2025–202679.6Sam Darnold
2018–202579.5Teddy Bridgewater2014–202179.2Ray Lucas
1999–199979.1Doug Flutie1999–200179.1Bo Nix2024–202679.0Kyle Orton2005–201478.8Vince Young2006–201078.4Jameis Winston2015–201978.4Byron Leftwich2003–200578.3Ryan Fitzpatrick2008–201978.1Shaun Hill2008–201478.1Elvis Grbac1999–200177.8Blake Bortles2014–201877.7Matt Leinart2006–200677.7Marcus Mariota2015–202577.6Chad Henne2009–201377.4Aaron Brooks2001–200576.8Drew Bledsoe1999–200576.1Tyrod Taylor2015–201775.8Geno Smith2013–202675.6Tyler Shough2025–202675.5Jason Campbell2007–201375.3Tarvaris Jackson2007–201175.2Sam Bradford2010–201675.1Jeff Blake1999–200374.8Troy Aikman1999–200074.7Tim Couch1999–200374.6Dan Marino1999–199974.6Jacoby Brissett2017–202674.4Alex Van Pelt2001–200173.3Nick Mullens2018–202073.2David Carr2002–200672.9Josh McCown2004–201772.9Mark Sanchez2009–201472.3Kenny Pickett2022–202372.2Trent Edwards2007–200872.0Colt McCoy2010–201172.0J.P. Losman2005–200671.8Chris Chandler
1999–200171.7Aidan O'Connell2023–202371.6Michael Penix Jr.2025–202571.5Joey Harrington2002–200771.3Cody Kessler2016–201671.2Kelly Holcomb2003–200571.2Damon Huard2006–200770.9Charlie Batch1999–200170.7Christian Ponder2011–201370.7Trevor Siemian2016–201770.7Justin Fields2021–202570.4Gardner Minshew2019–202470.4Gus Frerotte2005–200870.1Matt Moore2011–201170.1Jim Miller2001–200270.0Spencer Rattler2025–202569.8Kyle Boller2003–200769.4Cam Ward2025–202669.3Drew Stanton2014–201469.3Jim Harbaugh1999–199969.2Kent Graham1999–199968.9Chris Simms2005–200568.9Shaun King2000–200068.8Billy Volek2004–200468.8Rex Grossman2006–201168.5Anthony Richardson2024–202468.2Doug Johnson2003–200368.2Taylor Heinicke2021–202268.1Patrick Ramsey2003–200367.8Desmond Ridder2023–202367.7Blaine Gabbert2011–201567.5Kevin Kolb2011–201167.4Trent Dilfer1999–200567.2Rob Johnson2000–200167.1Tyler Thigpen2008–200867.0Quincy Carter2001–200367.0Seneca Wallace2008–200866.8Kellen Clemens2007–201366.8Kyle Allen2019–201966.4Will Levis2023–202466.2Tony Banks1999–200166.0Davis Mills2021–202265.9Rodney Peete2002–200265.9DeShone Kizer2017–201765.9Brett Hundley2017–201765.7Austin Davis2014–201465.5Joshua Dobbs2023–202365.5Tim Rattay2004–200465.5Malik Willis2026–202665.3Charlie Frye2006–200664.9Doug Pederson1999–200064.8Mike Glennon2013–201364.8Brandon Weeden2012–201264.5Sam Howell2023–202364.5EJ Manuel2013–201364.4Zach Wilson2021–202364.2Brian Hoyer2014–201563.5Brock Osweiler2016–201663.4Mason Rudolph2019–201963.2Jake Locker2012–201262.9Cade McNown2000–200062.8Rick Mirer2003–200362.4Terrelle Pryor2013–201362.4Anthony Wright2003–200362.2Chris Weinke2001–200161.8J.T. O'Sullivan2008–200861.6J.J. McCarthy2025–202561.4Drew Lock2020–202060.7JaMarcus Russell2008–200960.2Cooper Rush2024–202660.0A.J. Feeley2004–200459.9Brady Quinn2009–201259.4Ryan Leaf2000–200059.4Bruce Gradkowski2006–200659.3Brooks Bollinger2005–200558.9Tim Tebow2011–201157.8Curtis Painter2011–201156.5Andrew Walter2006–200654.1Chad Hutchinson2002–200253.2Akili Smith2000–200051.3Josh Rosen2018–201849.7Jimmy Clausen2010–201048.3
1999–2015104.0Tom Brady2001–2022101.3Drew Brees2002–2020101.2Patrick Mahomes2018–202697.6Philip Rivers2006–202097.1Aaron Rodgers2008–202697.0Matt Ryan2008–202296.0Josh Allen2018–202694.5Lamar Jackson2018–202694.4Brock Purdy2022–202693.2Tony Romo2006–201493.1Kurt Warner1999–200992.4Ben Roethlisberger2004–202191.5Daunte Culpepper2000–200491.4Brett Favre1999–201091.1Jared Goff2017–202690.8Trent Green2001–200690.6Steve McNair1999–200689.9Matt Schaub2007–201389.9Dak Prescott2016–202689.3Jayden Daniels2024–202689.2Russell Wilson2012–202489.1Carson Palmer2004–201688.9Ryan Tannehill2012–202388.4Andy Dalton2011–202288.3David Garrard2006–201088.2Jalen Hurts2021–202687.8Matt Hasselbeck2001–201587.7Justin Herbert2020–202687.1Jeff Garcia1999–200886.9Rich Gannon1999–200286.2Donovan McNabb2000–201085.8Jake Plummer1999–200685.6Marc Bulger2003–200985.6Matthew Stafford2009–202685.4Joe Flacco2008–202585.3Eli Manning2005–201885.2Jay Cutler2007–201785.0Joe Burrow2020–202684.9Drake Maye2024–202684.8Jay Fiedler2000–200384.7Caleb Williams2024–202684.7Baker Mayfield2018–202684.6Mike Vick2002–201284.5Nick Foles2013–201584.5Mitchell Trubisky2017–202084.4Brad Johnson1999–200684.4Colin Kaepernick2012–201684.3Jordan Love2023–202684.2Carson Wentz2016–202184.1Kerry Collins2000–200884.1Robert Griffin III2012–201383.9Chad Pennington2002–200883.8Tua Tagovailoa2020–202583.5Kirk Cousins2015–202683.5Brian Griese1999–200483.5Kyler Murray2019–202483.3Daniel Jones2019–202683.1Josh Freeman2009–201282.8Deshaun Watson2018–202682.2Jake Delhomme2003–200982.2Mac Jones2021–202582.1Kordell Stewart1999–200182.1Andrew Luck2012–201882.1Derek Carr2014–202481.8Tommy Maddox2002–200381.7Alex Smith2006–201881.7Case Keenum2013–201981.6Jon Kitna1999–201081.6Trevor Lawrence2021–202681.5C.J. Stroud2023–202681.3Mark Brunell1999–200681.2Jimmy Garoppolo2019–202281.2Bryce Young2023–202680.9Matt Cassel2008–201280.5Steve Beuerlein1999–200080.2Jeff George1999–199980.1Vinny Testaverde2000–200479.9Cam Newton2011–202079.8Derek Anderson2007–201079.8Jaxson Dart2025–202679.6Sam Darnold2018–202579.5Teddy Bridgewater2014–202179.2Ray Lucas1999–199979.1Doug Flutie1999–200179.1Bo Nix2024–202679.0Kyle Orton2005–201478.8Vince Young2006–201078.4Jameis Winston2015–201978.4Byron Leftwich2003–200578.3Ryan Fitzpatrick2008–201978.1Shaun Hill2008–201478.1Elvis Grbac1999–200177.8Blake Bortles2014–201877.7Matt Leinart2006–200677.7Marcus Mariota2015–202577.6Chad Henne2009–201377.4Aaron Brooks2001–200576.8Drew Bledsoe1999–200576.1Tyrod Taylor2015–201775.8Geno Smith2013–202675.6Tyler Shough2025–202675.5Jason Campbell2007–201375.3Tarvaris Jackson2007–201175.2Sam Bradford2010–201675.1Jeff Blake1999–200374.8Troy Aikman1999–200074.7Tim Couch1999–200374.6Dan Marino1999–199974.6Jacoby Brissett2017–202674.4Alex Van Pelt2001–200173.3Nick Mullens2018–202073.2David Carr2002–200672.9Josh McCown2004–201772.9Mark Sanchez2009–201472.3Kenny Pickett2022–202372.2Trent Edwards2007–200872.0Colt McCoy2010–201172.0J.P. Losman2005–200671.8Chris Chandler1999–200171.7Aidan O'Connell2023–202371.6Michael Penix Jr.2025–202571.5Joey Harrington2002–200771.3Cody Kessler2016–201671.2Kelly Holcomb2003–200571.2Damon Huard2006–200770.9Charlie Batch1999–200170.7Christian Ponder2011–201370.7Trevor Siemian2016–201770.7Justin Fields2021–202570.4Gardner Minshew2019–202470.4Gus Frerotte2005–200870.1Matt Moore2011–201170.1Jim Miller2001–200270.0Spencer Rattler2025–202569.8Kyle Boller2003–200769.4Cam Ward2025–202669.3Drew Stanton2014–201469.3Jim Harbaugh1999–199969.2Kent Graham1999–199968.9Chris Simms2005–200568.9Shaun King2000–200068.8Billy Volek2004–200468.8Rex Grossman2006–201168.5Anthony Richardson2024–202468.2Doug Johnson2003–200368.2Taylor Heinicke2021–202268.1Patrick Ramsey2003–200367.8Desmond Ridder2023–202367.7Blaine Gabbert2011–201567.5Kevin Kolb2011–201167.4Trent Dilfer1999–200567.2Rob Johnson2000–200167.1Tyler Thigpen2008–200867.0Quincy Carter2001–200367.0Seneca Wallace2008–200866.8Kellen Clemens2007–201366.8Kyle Allen2019–201966.4Will Levis2023–202466.2Tony Banks1999–200166.0Davis Mills2021–202265.9Rodney Peete2002–200265.9DeShone Kizer2017–201765.9Brett Hundley2017–201765.7Austin Davis2014–201465.5Joshua Dobbs2023–202365.5Tim Rattay2004–200465.5Malik Willis2026–202665.3Charlie Frye2006–200664.9Doug Pederson1999–200064.8Mike Glennon2013–201364.8Brandon Weeden2012–201264.5Sam Howell2023–202364.5EJ Manuel2013–201364.4Zach Wilson2021–202364.2Brian Hoyer2014–201563.5Brock Osweiler2016–201663.4Mason Rudolph2019–201963.2Jake Locker2012–201262.9Cade McNown2000–200062.8Rick Mirer2003–200362.4Terrelle Pryor2013–201362.4Anthony Wright2003–200362.2Chris Weinke2001–200161.8J.T. O'Sullivan2008–200861.6J.J. McCarthy2025–202561.4Drew Lock2020–202060.7JaMarcus Russell2008–200960.2Cooper Rush2024–202660.0A.J. Feeley2004–200459.9Brady Quinn2009–201259.4Ryan Leaf2000–200059.4Bruce Gradkowski2006–200659.3Brooks Bollinger2005–200558.9Tim Tebow2011–201157.8Curtis Painter2011–201156.5Andrew Walter2006–200654.1Chad Hutchinson2002–200253.2Akili Smith2000–200051.3Josh Rosen2018–201849.7Jimmy Clausen2010–201048.3