---
title: "Phil Simms | Held Out"
description: "BRADY ratings for Phil Simms by season and week, with wins above replacement per start."
url: "https://heldout.org/quarterbacks/search/00-0014922"
---

# Phil Simms

- [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1993) 1979–1993

Peak Season 79.8

1986, ranked #8

WAR per Start 0.128

169 starts

Top-5 Seasons 0

0 at number one

Awards 0

None

## Phil Simms: BRADY by Season

## Every Season

|      |                               |           |      |         |    | Honors |
| ---- | ----------------------------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | -- | ------ |
| 1993 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1993) | **0.141** | 76.2 | #12     | 18 |        |
| 1992 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1992) | **0.147** | 76.5 | Partial | 4  |        |
| 1991 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1991) | **0.152** | 77.0 | Partial | 4  |        |
| 1990 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1990) | **0.137** | 75.3 | #15     | 14 |        |
| 1989 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1989) | **0.131** | 74.4 | #16     | 16 |        |
| 1988 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1988) | **0.135** | 74.5 | #14     | 15 |        |
| 1987 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1987) | **0.178** | 77.9 | #8      | 9  |        |
| 1986 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1986) | **0.200** | 79.8 | #8      | 19 |        |
| 1985 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1985) | **0.113** | 70.6 | #22     | 18 |        |
| 1984 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1984) | **0.083** | 68.0 | #24     | 18 |        |
| 1981 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1981) | **0.020** | 62.4 | #29     | 10 |        |
| 1980 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1980) | **0.016** | 61.9 | #28     | 13 |        |
| 1979 | [NYG](/teams/search/NYG/1979) | **0.064** | 66.0 | #28     | 11 |        |

Too few starts to rank (under 8 in a full season)

## Data

- [matchups/results.json](/data/matchups/results.json)
- [matchups/upcoming.json](/data/matchups/upcoming.json)
- [quarterbacks/00-0014922.json](/data/quarterbacks/00-0014922.json)

Theme 

Updated Nov 10, 2026, 9:37 PM PST © 2026, Aditya Kishore. All rights reserved. For Commercial Licensing or Questions: [Contact Held Out](/contact) Club marks are trademarks of their clubs. Past marks: [SportsLogoHistory.com](https://sportslogohistory.com/nfl-primary-logo/).