---
title: "Look Up a Quarterback — Held Out"
description: "Any NFL starter’s BRADY rating since 1999, season by season and week by week."
url: "https://heldout.org/quarterbacks/search"
---

# BRADY Quarterback Rankings

Every starter since 1999, on the same scale as RICE. [How it works](/methodology/brady)

Quarterback Team Seasons Peak

- [Peyton Manning DEN 1999–2015 104.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0010346)
- [Tom Brady TB 2001–2022 101.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019596)
- [Drew Brees NO 2002–2020 101.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020531)
- [Patrick Mahomes KC 2018–2026 97.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033873)
- [Philip Rivers IND 2006–2020 97.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022942)
- [Aaron Rodgers PIT 2008–2026 97.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023459)
- [Matt Ryan IND 2008–2022 96.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026143)
- [Josh Allen BUF 2018–2026 94.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034857)
- [Lamar Jackson BAL 2018–2026 94.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034796)
- [Brock Purdy SF 2022–2026 93.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0037834)
- [Tony Romo DAL 2006–2014 93.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021678)
- [Kurt Warner ARI 1999–2009 92.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0017200)
- [Ben Roethlisberger PIT 2004–2021 91.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022924)
- [Daunte Culpepper MIN 2000–2004 91.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0003739)
- [Brett Favre MIN 1999–2010 91.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005106)
- [Jared Goff DET 2017–2026 90.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033106)
- [Trent Green KC 2001–2006 90.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0006355)
- [Steve McNair BAL 1999–2006 89.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0011024)
- [Matt Schaub HOU 2007–2013 89.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022787)
- [Dak Prescott DAL 2016–2026 89.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033077)
- [Jayden Daniels WAS 2024–2026 89.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039910)
- [Russell Wilson PIT 2012–2024 89.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029263)
- [Carson Palmer ARI 2004–2016 88.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021429)
- [Ryan Tannehill TEN 2012–2023 88.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029701)
- [Andy Dalton NO 2011–2022 88.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027973)
- [David Garrard JAX 2006–2010 88.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021231)
- [Jalen Hurts PHI 2021–2026 87.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036389)
- [Matt Hasselbeck IND 2001–2015 87.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0007091)
- [Justin Herbert LAC 2020–2026 87.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036355)
- [Jeff Garcia TB 1999–2008 86.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005755)
- [Rich Gannon LV 1999–2002 86.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005741)
- [Donovan McNabb WAS 2000–2010 85.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0011022)
- [Jake Plummer DEN 1999–2006 85.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0013042)
- [Marc Bulger LA 2003–2009 85.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019599)
- [Matthew Stafford LA 2009–2026 85.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026498)
- [Joe Flacco CIN 2008–2025 85.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026158)
- [Eli Manning NYG 2005–2018 85.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022803)
- [Jay Cutler MIA 2007–2017 85.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024226)
- [Joe Burrow CIN 2020–2026 84.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036442)
- [Drake Maye NE 2024–2026 84.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039851)
- [Jay Fiedler MIA 2000–2003 84.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005180)
- [Caleb Williams CHI 2024–2026 84.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039918)
- [Baker Mayfield TB 2018–2026 84.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034855)
- [Mike Vick PHI 2002–2012 84.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020245)
- [Nick Foles LA 2013–2015 84.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029567)
- [Mitchell Trubisky CHI 2017–2020 84.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033869)
- [Brad Johnson MIN 1999–2006 84.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0008442)
- [Colin Kaepernick SF 2012–2016 84.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027974)
- [Jordan Love GB 2023–2026 84.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036264)
- [Carson Wentz IND 2016–2021 84.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0032950)
- [Kerry Collins TEN 2000–2008 84.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0003292)
- [Robert Griffin III WAS 2012–2013 83.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029665)
- [Chad Pennington MIA 2002–2008 83.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019559)
- [Tua Tagovailoa MIA 2020–2025 83.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036212)
- [Kirk Cousins LV 2015–2026 83.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029604)
- [Brian Griese TB 1999–2004 83.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0006423)
- [Kyler Murray ARI 2019–2024 83.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0035228)
- [Daniel Jones IND 2019–2026 83.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0035710)
- [Josh Freeman TB 2009–2012 82.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026993)
- [Deshaun Watson CLE 2018–2026 82.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033537)
- [Jake Delhomme CAR 2003–2009 82.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0004161)
- [Mac Jones SF 2021–2025 82.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036972)
- [Kordell Stewart PIT 1999–2001 82.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0015700)
- [Andrew Luck IND 2012–2018 82.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029668)
- [Derek Carr NO 2014–2024 81.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031280)
- [Tommy Maddox PIT 2002–2003 81.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0010261)
- [Alex Smith WAS 2006–2018 81.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023436)
- [Case Keenum WAS 2013–2019 81.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0028986)
- [Jon Kitna DAL 1999–2010 81.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0009311)
- [Trevor Lawrence JAX 2021–2026 81.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036971)
- [C.J. Stroud HOU 2023–2026 81.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039163)
- [Mark Brunell WAS 1999–2006 81.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0002110)
- [Jimmy Garoppolo SF 2019–2022 81.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031345)
- [Bryce Young CAR 2023–2026 80.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039150)
- [Matt Cassel KC 2008–2012 80.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023662)
- [Steve Beuerlein CAR 1999–2000 80.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0001218)
- [Jeff George MIN 1999–1999 80.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005885)
- [Vinny Testaverde DAL 2000–2004 79.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0016193)
- [Cam Newton NE 2011–2020 79.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027939)
- [Derek Anderson ARI 2007–2010 79.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023645)
- [Jaxson Dart NYG 2025–2026 79.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0040691)
- [Sam Darnold SEA 2018–2025 79.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034869)
- [Teddy Bridgewater DEN 2014–2021 79.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031237)
- [Ray Lucas NYJ 1999–1999 79.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0010137)
- [Doug Flutie LAC 1999–2001 79.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005363)
- [Bo Nix DEN 2024–2026 79.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039732)
- [Kyle Orton BUF 2005–2014 78.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023541)
- [Vince Young TEN 2006–2010 78.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024218)
- [Jameis Winston TB 2015–2019 78.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031503)
- [Byron Leftwich JAX 2003–2005 78.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022177)
- [Ryan Fitzpatrick MIA 2008–2019 78.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023682)
- [Shaun Hill LA 2008–2014 78.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020679)
- [Elvis Grbac BAL 1999–2001 77.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0006300)
- [Blake Bortles JAX 2014–2018 77.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031407)
- [Matt Leinart ARI 2006–2006 77.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024225)
- [Marcus Mariota WAS 2015–2025 77.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0032268)
- [Chad Henne JAX 2009–2013 77.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026197)
- [Aaron Brooks NO 2001–2005 76.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0001823)
- [Drew Bledsoe DAL 1999–2005 76.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0001361)
- [Tyrod Taylor BUF 2015–2017 75.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0028118)
- [Geno Smith NYJ 2013–2026 75.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0030565)
- [Tyler Shough NO 2025–2026 75.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0040743)
- [Jason Campbell CLE 2007–2013 75.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023460)
- [Tarvaris Jackson SEA 2007–2011 75.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024279)
- [Sam Bradford MIN 2010–2016 75.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027854)
- [Jeff Blake ARI 1999–2003 74.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0001335)
- [Troy Aikman DAL 1999–2000 74.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0000104)
- [Tim Couch CLE 1999–2003 74.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0003535)
- [Dan Marino MIA 1999–1999 74.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0010379)
- [Jacoby Brissett ARI 2017–2026 74.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033119)
- [Alex Van Pelt BUF 2001–2001 73.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0016838)
- [Nick Mullens SF 2018–2020 73.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033319)
- [David Carr HOU 2002–2006 72.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020608)
- [Josh McCown NYJ 2004–2017 72.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021206)
- [Mark Sanchez PHI 2009–2014 72.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026898)
- [Kenny Pickett PIT 2022–2023 72.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0038102)
- [Trent Edwards BUF 2007–2008 72.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025479)
- [Colt McCoy CLE 2010–2011 72.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027688)
- [J.P. Losman BUF 2005–2006 71.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022912)
- [Chris Chandler ATL 1999–2001 71.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0002876)
- [Aidan O'Connell LV 2023–2023 71.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0038579)
- [Michael Penix Jr. ATL 2025–2025 71.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039917)
- [Joey Harrington ATL 2002–2007 71.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021141)
- [Cody Kessler CLE 2016–2016 71.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033104)
- [Kelly Holcomb BUF 2003–2005 71.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0007576)
- [Damon Huard KC 2006–2007 70.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0007835)
- [Charlie Batch DET 1999–2001 70.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0000865)
- [Christian Ponder MIN 2011–2013 70.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027950)
- [Trevor Siemian DEN 2016–2017 70.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0032156)
- [Justin Fields NYJ 2021–2025 70.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036945)
- [Gardner Minshew LV 2019–2024 70.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0035289)
- [Gus Frerotte MIN 2005–2008 70.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0005589)
- [Matt Moore MIA 2011–2011 70.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025708)
- [Jim Miller CHI 2001–2002 70.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0011276)
- [Spencer Rattler NO 2025–2025 69.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039376)
- [Kyle Boller BAL 2003–2007 69.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022164)
- [Cam Ward TEN 2025–2026 69.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0040676)
- [Drew Stanton ARI 2014–2014 69.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025430)
- [Jim Harbaugh LAC 1999–1999 69.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0006808)
- [Kent Graham NYG 1999–1999 68.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0006212)
- [Chris Simms TB 2005–2005 68.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022005)
- [Shaun King TB 2000–2000 68.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0009266)
- [Billy Volek TEN 2004–2004 68.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019041)
- [Rex Grossman WAS 2006–2011 68.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022121)
- [Anthony Richardson IND 2024–2024 68.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039164)
- [Doug Johnson ATL 2003–2003 68.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019087)
- [Taylor Heinicke WAS 2021–2022 68.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031800)
- [Patrick Ramsey WAS 2003–2003 67.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021379)
- [Desmond Ridder ATL 2023–2023 67.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0038122)
- [Blaine Gabbert SF 2011–2015 67.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027948)
- [Kevin Kolb ARI 2011–2011 67.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025423)
- [Trent Dilfer CLE 1999–2005 67.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0004293)
- [Rob Johnson BUF 2000–2001 67.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0008612)
- [Tyler Thigpen KC 2008–2008 67.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025604)
- [Quincy Carter DAL 2001–2003 67.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020404)
- [Seneca Wallace SEA 2008–2008 66.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022055)
- [Kellen Clemens LA 2007–2013 66.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024264)
- [Kyle Allen CAR 2019–2019 66.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034577)
- [Will Levis TEN 2023–2024 66.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039152)
- [Tony Banks WAS 1999–2001 66.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0000722)
- [Davis Mills HOU 2021–2022 65.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0036898)
- [Rodney Peete CAR 2002–2002 65.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0012732)
- [DeShone Kizer CLE 2017–2017 65.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033899)
- [Brett Hundley GB 2017–2017 65.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0031589)
- [Austin Davis LA 2014–2014 65.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0028957)
- [Joshua Dobbs MIN 2023–2023 65.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033949)
- [Tim Rattay SF 2004–2004 65.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0019623)
- [Malik Willis MIA 2026–2026 65.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0038128)
- [Charlie Frye CLE 2006–2006 64.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023502)
- [Doug Pederson CLE 1999–2000 64.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0012726)
- [Mike Glennon TB 2013–2013 64.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0030520)
- [Brandon Weeden CLE 2012–2012 64.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029677)
- [Sam Howell WAS 2023–2023 64.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0037077)
- [EJ Manuel BUF 2013–2013 64.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0030526)
- [Zach Wilson NYJ 2021–2023 64.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0037013)
- [Brian Hoyer HOU 2014–2015 63.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0026625)
- [Brock Osweiler HOU 2016–2016 63.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0029682)
- [Mason Rudolph PIT 2019–2019 63.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034771)
- [Jake Locker TEN 2012–2012 62.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027946)
- [Cade McNown CHI 2000–2000 62.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0011044)
- [Rick Mirer LV 2003–2003 62.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0011378)
- [Terrelle Pryor LV 2013–2013 62.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0028825)
- [Anthony Wright BAL 2003–2003 62.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0018272)
- [Chris Weinke CAR 2001–2001 61.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020434)
- [J.T. O'Sullivan SF 2008–2008 61.6](/quarterbacks/search/00-0021296)
- [J.J. McCarthy MIN 2025–2025 61.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0039923)
- [Drew Lock DEN 2020–2020 60.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0035704)
- [JaMarcus Russell LV 2008–2009 60.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025388)
- [Cooper Rush ATL 2024–2026 60.0](/quarterbacks/search/00-0033662)
- [A.J. Feeley MIA 2004–2004 59.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020305)
- [Brady Quinn KC 2009–2012 59.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0025409)
- [Ryan Leaf LAC 2000–2000 59.4](/quarterbacks/search/00-0009715)
- [Bruce Gradkowski TB 2006–2006 59.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0024408)
- [Brooks Bollinger NYJ 2005–2005 58.9](/quarterbacks/search/00-0022026)
- [Tim Tebow DEN 2011–2011 57.8](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027876)
- [Curtis Painter IND 2011–2011 56.5](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027134)
- [Andrew Walter LV 2006–2006 54.1](/quarterbacks/search/00-0023504)
- [Chad Hutchinson DAL 2002–2002 53.2](/quarterbacks/search/00-0020562)
- [Akili Smith CIN 2000–2000 51.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0015082)
- [Josh Rosen ARI 2018–2018 49.7](/quarterbacks/search/00-0034343)
- [Jimmy Clausen CAR 2010–2010 48.3](/quarterbacks/search/00-0027659)

## Data

- [quarterbacks/index.json](/data/quarterbacks/index.json)

Last Updated: Sep 26, 2026, 3:56 PM PDT © 2026, Aditya Kishore. All Rights Reserved. Club marks are the clubs’ own trademarks. Past marks courtesy of [SportsLogoHistory.com](https://sportslogohistory.com/nfl-primary-logo/) and data courtesy of [nflverse](https://nflverse.nflverse.com/).